Jon Snow? Yes but he was resurrectedCaptain Punish wrote:Has the midget died yet?
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-G920I using The Greenhouse mobile app powered by Tapatalk
Moderator: GH Moderators
Jon Snow? Yes but he was resurrectedCaptain Punish wrote:Has the midget died yet?
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Yeah I think she's foxing. That first scene where she was reading the note out loud was not like her. I think she was putting it on to try and get Littlefingers attention.Northern Raider wrote: Third point was the tension between Arya and Sansa came across a bit too contrived for my liking. Unless Arya is playing some sort of counter espionage on Littlefinger I'm not really buying it.
He's Coldhands from the book. The books never reveal his identity so could be Benjen Stark. Otherwise its likely the TV series melded 2 characters into one, which they've done a few times now. Can't have too many characters in the TV series especially some random good guy undead.The Nickman wrote:Uncle Benjen?? He's Ned Stark's brother, was a man of the Night's Watch, went beyond the wall at the start and never returned. It was revealed when he saved Bran in the north that he was undead now, but for some reason kept his mind.
But he's dead now, so they'll probably not even explain **** is the go with Benjen's story.
Nah, I knew Coldhands was Benjen Stark when I was reading the books, I just assumed the show spoiled it for me. Hopefully in the books they tell us his story.Northern Raider wrote:He's Coldhands from the book. The books never reveal his identity so could be Benjen Stark. Otherwise its likely the TV series melded 2 characters into one, which they've done a few times now. Can't have too many characters in the TV series especially some random good guy undead.The Nickman wrote:Uncle Benjen?? He's Ned Stark's brother, was a man of the Night's Watch, went beyond the wall at the start and never returned. It was revealed when he saved Bran in the north that he was undead now, but for some reason kept his mind.
But he's dead now, so they'll probably not even explain **** is the go with Benjen's story.
I'm telling you now, LF is dead next EpFuifui Bradbrad wrote:Yeah I think she's foxing. That first scene where she was reading the note out loud was not like her. I think she was putting it on to try and get Littlefingers attention.Northern Raider wrote: Third point was the tension between Arya and Sansa came across a bit too contrived for my liking. Unless Arya is playing some sort of counter espionage on Littlefinger I'm not really buying it.
No arguments here. Even that scene where LF was trying to talk Sansa into getting Brienne to kill Arya, I got the feeling Sansa had him right where she wants him.Pigman wrote:I'm telling you now, LF is dead next EpFuifui Bradbrad wrote:Yeah I think she's foxing. That first scene where she was reading the note out loud was not like her. I think she was putting it on to try and get Littlefingers attention.Northern Raider wrote: Third point was the tension between Arya and Sansa came across a bit too contrived for my liking. Unless Arya is playing some sort of counter espionage on Littlefinger I'm not really buying it.
The sisters have this ****
No, she doesn't have Sansa's face yetBrewdle wrote:It's like LotR, why didn't they just use the giant eagles to fly the ring to Mordor, why didn't Dany just jump on a dragon and go grab a white walker?
Anyone else think it was Arya who sent Brienne away after overhearing the conversation between Littlefinger and Sansa?
Sent from my iPhone using The Greenhouse mobile app powered by Tapatalk
Hahahahahaha amazing analogy... wonder if Brisbane Raider has a better one?gangrenous wrote:Seems to me like cheering for the Starks is a lot like supporting the Raiders. These guys have all the talent in the world but just make dumb decision after dumb decision. Their team leaders lose their heads in the critical moments. Sansa looks like a freakin genius by comparison because she kicks a 40/20 with Littlefinger's army to win one game. Arya is busy calling Sansa an FGC and they're probably going to have to swap the positions of her and Jon to stop the petty in-fighting. Jon has just kicked a dragon dead and gifted the White Walkers a 7 tackle set. Not to mention constantly being tackled on the last play. Benjin is forever in no mans land, barely sighted, and has done about two useful things in seven seasons to hold his position.
Dany isn't much better, sends in her backs to do the hard yards and then brings out the hulking dragons in the red zone.
All the while the Iron Bank are happy to keep jamming Cersei down Westeros' throats every Friday for short term profit. But there's only so many old houses you can just wipe out and take their gold. No long term planning whatsoever. They'd love to see the Starks wither on the vine. It's too **** cold in Winterfell anyway.
Chrildren of the Forrest said in the books that Coldhands died a very long time ago. Considering they are centuries old themselves I doubt they would use that description for somebody who died a few years ago.The Nickman wrote:Nah, I knew Coldhands was Benjen Stark when I was reading the books, I just assumed the show spoiled it for me. Hopefully in the books they tell us his story.Northern Raider wrote:He's Coldhands from the book. The books never reveal his identity so could be Benjen Stark. Otherwise its likely the TV series melded 2 characters into one, which they've done a few times now. Can't have too many characters in the TV series especially some random good guy undead.The Nickman wrote:Uncle Benjen?? He's Ned Stark's brother, was a man of the Night's Watch, went beyond the wall at the start and never returned. It was revealed when he saved Bran in the north that he was undead now, but for some reason kept his mind.
But he's dead now, so they'll probably not even explain **** is the go with Benjen's story.
It just dawned on me rewatching the latest episode... if Dany had just flown in and torched the Night King and his generals the whole thing would be over.
Lolololol!!!The Nickman wrote:Hahahahahaha amazing analogy... wonder if Brisbane Raider has a better one?gangrenous wrote:Seems to me like cheering for the Starks is a lot like supporting the Raiders. These guys have all the talent in the world but just make dumb decision after dumb decision. Their team leaders lose their heads in the critical moments. Sansa looks like a freakin genius by comparison because she kicks a 40/20 with Littlefinger's army to win one game. Arya is busy calling Sansa an FGC and they're probably going to have to swap the positions of her and Jon to stop the petty in-fighting. Jon has just kicked a dragon dead and gifted the White Walkers a 7 tackle set. Not to mention constantly being tackled on the last play. Benjin is forever in no mans land, barely sighted, and has done about two useful things in seven seasons to hold his position.
Dany isn't much better, sends in her backs to do the hard yards and then brings out the hulking dragons in the red zone.
All the while the Iron Bank are happy to keep jamming Cersei down Westeros' throats every Friday for short term profit. But there's only so many old houses you can just wipe out and take their gold. No long term planning whatsoever. They'd love to see the Starks wither on the vine. It's too **** cold in Winterfell anyway.
Huh... I missed that bit. Re-reading the books again now, hopefully pick up a lot more on the second go through.Northern Raider wrote:Chrildren of the Forrest said in the books that Coldhands died a very long time ago. Considering they are centuries old themselves I doubt they would use that description for somebody who died a few years ago.The Nickman wrote:Nah, I knew Coldhands was Benjen Stark when I was reading the books, I just assumed the show spoiled it for me. Hopefully in the books they tell us his story.Northern Raider wrote:He's Coldhands from the book. The books never reveal his identity so could be Benjen Stark. Otherwise its likely the TV series melded 2 characters into one, which they've done a few times now. Can't have too many characters in the TV series especially some random good guy undead.The Nickman wrote:Uncle Benjen?? He's Ned Stark's brother, was a man of the Night's Watch, went beyond the wall at the start and never returned. It was revealed when he saved Bran in the north that he was undead now, but for some reason kept his mind.
But he's dead now, so they'll probably not even explain **** is the go with Benjen's story.
It just dawned on me rewatching the latest episode... if Dany had just flown in and torched the Night King and his generals the whole thing would be over.
Sent from my SM-G920I using The Greenhouse mobile app powered by Tapatalk
Despite it's lack of proper explanation the TV series version of Coldhands/Benjen ties in with the story better than the books.The Nickman wrote:Just reading up on theories on Coldhands now too, apparently in an original manuscript, George R.R Martin declared that Coldhands was not Benjen Stark...
So I wonder what the **** HAS happened to Uncle Benjen in the books??
None of that **** bothered me, but I don't buy Dany flying in at speed in those conditions without even a beanie on.The Nickman wrote:It was good, but it was a bit ridiculous too! Seriously, how long were they camped there surrounded by zombies for:-GD- wrote:What an incredible episode though!!
a) Gendry to run all the way back to Eastwatch
2) a raven to fly all the way to Dragonstone
d) Dany to fly her dragons to the north
I mean seriously?? This REALLY bugged me!
I said that to the other half on Monday, without the Night King. I was thinking that Jon is the Fire and Ice, and the song of Fire and Ice will be the song/story that Sam writes in honour of Jon.The Nickman wrote:I think it has some merit. And it seems to me that Dany (a Targaryen) is fire, the Night King (a Stark, possibly Bran), is ice, and Jon Snow (as a Targaryen/Stark) is the Song of Ice and Fire and will have to "bring balance to the force" so to speak
Yeah I've read the "whole thing is written by Sam at the citadel" theory too. Not real sure about that oneFuifui Bradbrad wrote:I said that to the other half on Monday, without the Night King. I was thinking that Jon is the Fire and Ice, and the song of Fire and Ice will be the song/story that Sam writes in honour of Jon.The Nickman wrote:I think it has some merit. And it seems to me that Dany (a Targaryen) is fire, the Night King (a Stark, possibly Bran), is ice, and Jon Snow (as a Targaryen/Stark) is the Song of Ice and Fire and will have to "bring balance to the force" so to speak
Or just this whole story, was written by Sam
Time travel.Manchild wrote:How could Bran be the night king? Isnt the night king old AF?
Also Jon **** Snow is becoming hopeless. Why the **** did he run down after all the fighting was done and try be a hero.
The bloke hardly swung a sword the entire time the crew were fighting for their lives and then suddenly Deny rocks up and he wants to show off like a 12yo with a crush. Cost the woman a dragon and he is still the hero in her eyes. ****.