‘Pretty disappointed’: Raiders to lodge complaint over Sharks trainer’s bizarre move
The Canberra Raiders will reportedly lodge a formal complaint with the NRL after claiming a Sharks trainer purposely tried to distract goalkicker Jamal Fogarty as he was attempting an important sideline conversion. The Raiders were trailing 30-22 with just over seven minutes on the clock at the time of the kick following a James Schiller try. A successful conversion would have put Canberra to within a try.
Footage from Fox Sports cameras captured Sharks trainer Daniel Holdsworth running down the sideline just metres from Fogarty as he was running into kick.
I thought it looked odd during the live coverage too:
Ultima wrote: ↑March 31, 2024, 6:55 pm
.... Did that trainer run past him as he was kicking to put him off?
Goal kicking in general the refs don't seem like they want to enforce any of the rules. I keep waiting for a kicker to complain players aren't behind the line during a kick and demanding a do over.
That incident was popping off on my group chats
I was too annoyed at the level of football we were playing to be too concerned about it in the moment but I think it’s a fair complaint
Trainer has no business being in a position where he could adversely impact the goal kicker
Why should we stay quiet? I don’t understand why so many people say “shush” when we’re just standing up for ourselves. We shouldn’t stay silent when we’re not being given a fair go. The people at the NRL in Sydney would prefer to ignore us, and have things swept under the carpet.
greeneyed wrote:Why should we stay quiet? I don’t understand why so many people say “shush” when we’re just standing up for ourselves. We shouldn’t stay silent when we’re not being given a fair go. The people at the NRL in Sydney would prefer to ignore us, and have things swept under the carpet.
Cause when it has zero impact on the outcome of the game they just look like a sook and a sore loser
GreenMachine wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 1:40 pm
Imagine the only complaint our football club had over the game was the shark's trainer and not the abysmal football we play....
I mean I get that it's not a great look from the Sharks trainer, but given how terribly amateurish we played it just stinks of sour grapes.
GreenMachine wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 1:40 pm
Imagine the only complaint our football club had over the game was the shark's trainer and not the abysmal football we play....
I mean I get that it's not a great look from the Sharks trainer, but given how terribly amateurish we played it just stinks of sour grapes.
That's the downside. It's a completely reasonable thing to complain about. The trainer I no right to do it. But coming from the losing team it just looks like whinging.
greeneyed wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 11:37 am
Why should we stay quiet? I don’t understand why so many people say “shush” when we’re just standing up for ourselves. We shouldn’t stay silent when we’re not being given a fair go. The people at the NRL in Sydney would prefer to ignore us, and have things swept under the carpet.
Don't you mean they'd prefer we would "wither on the vine"?
greeneyed wrote:Why should we stay quiet? I don’t understand why so many people say “shush” when we’re just standing up for ourselves. We shouldn’t stay silent when we’re not being given a fair go. The people at the NRL in Sydney would prefer to ignore us, and have things swept under the carpet.
Cause when it has zero impact on the outcome of the game they just look like a sook and a sore loser
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
It will have no impact on the outcome of the game, but it should have an impact on ensuring that procedures are fair and reasonable in the future. The NRL isn't protecting our interests unless we stand up for ourselves... who cares what Sharks fans think?
Yeah this whole talk about how it looks is dumb. Nobody at the club is claiming it cost us the game and it isn't unreasonable to want to hold the trainer accountable.
I don't post often, but by god do I browse on here full time. It's like a sandpit filled with decent jokes. The aggro thing some of you have going on against each other is also hilarious.
I had to say something. I love yous all.
-PJ- wrote: ↑April 14, 2024, 9:07 pm
I thought it went really good, now let’s go get some soft serve.
GreenMachine wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 1:40 pm
Imagine the only complaint our football club had over the game was the shark's trainer and not the abysmal football we play....
I mean I get that it's not a great look from the Sharks trainer, but given how terribly amateurish we played it just stinks of sour grapes.
That's the downside. It's a completely reasonable thing to complain about. The trainer I no right to do it. But coming from the losing team it just looks like whinging.
I think if you listen to Ricky's press conference we are certainly not blaming the trainer
GreenMachine wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 1:40 pm
Imagine the only complaint our football club had over the game was the shark's trainer and not the abysmal football we play....
I mean I get that it's not a great look from the Sharks trainer, but given how terribly amateurish we played it just stinks of sour grapes.
That's the downside. It's a completely reasonable thing to complain about. The trainer I no right to do it. But coming from the losing team it just looks like whinging.
I think if you listen to Ricky's press conference we are certainly not blaming the trainer
I did not say that we did. Just commenting on the optics of it.
GreenMachine wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 1:40 pm
Imagine the only complaint our football club had over the game was the shark's trainer and not the abysmal football we play....
I mean I get that it's not a great look from the Sharks trainer, but given how terribly amateurish we played it just stinks of sour grapes.
That's the downside. It's a completely reasonable thing to complain about. The trainer I no right to do it. But coming from the losing team it just looks like whinging.
I think if you listen to Ricky's press conference we are certainly not blaming the trainer
I did not say that we did. Just commenting on the optics of it.
Yeah exactly. There’s one goose in this thread who always tries to assume the moral high ground and call everybody else dumb, but when we turned in such a terrible performance the optics absolutely are worth calling attention to.
'There's no way he can get in trouble' says former Sharks forward Paul Gallen, while Raiders left fuming
The NRL is considering issuing the Cronulla Sharks with a breach notice after Raiders officials lodged a formal complaint over the actions of Sharks trainer Daniel Holdsworth. He ran close by Raiders halfback Jamal Fogarty, just as the half was taking a crucial conversion attempt from the sideline.
"The Sharks trainer is something we're considering at the moment," NRL head of football Graham Annesley said. "Any of those sorts of things have potential for breach notices issued to clubs. That ultimately goes through a different internal process and that can take a couple of days for that to happen.
Azza wrote:
I mean I get that it's not a great look from the Sharks trainer, but given how terribly amateurish we played it just stinks of sour grapes.
That's the downside. It's a completely reasonable thing to complain about. The trainer I no right to do it. But coming from the losing team it just looks like whinging.
I think if you listen to Ricky's press conference we are certainly not blaming the trainer
I did not say that we did. Just commenting on the optics of it.
Yeah exactly. There’s one goose in this thread who always tries to assume the moral high ground and call everybody else dumb, but when we turned in such a terrible performance the optics absolutely are worth calling attention to.
Are you suggesting you can only complain if you win? Anyway I can assure both the winning team and losing team whinge to the NRL after every game.
Dr Zaius wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 2:48 pm
That's the downside. It's a completely reasonable thing to complain about. The trainer I no right to do it. But coming from the losing team it just looks like whinging.
I think if you listen to Ricky's press conference we are certainly not blaming the trainer
I did not say that we did. Just commenting on the optics of it.
Yeah exactly. There’s one goose in this thread who always tries to assume the moral high ground and call everybody else dumb, but when we turned in such a terrible performance the optics absolutely are worth calling attention to.
Are you suggesting you can only complain if you win? Anyway I can assure both the winning team and losing team whinge to the NRL after every game.
If that response would irritate you the most, then yes.
-PJ- wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 12:06 pm
I think the Sharks trainer should be tasered.
Or be forced to watch 12 continuous hours of Raiders grindball highlights
I like the cut of your jib.
PS what's a jib?
PPS does PJ work for NSW police?
Hi Azza,
A jib is the triangular sail at the front of a ship. I believe the particular shape (cut) of the jib on old ships made their nationality recognisable from a distance.
Also, to be included in the lowlights reel could be Starling refuse to pass to anyone after making a brief run / receiving an offload.
-PJ- wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 12:06 pm
I think the Sharks trainer should be tasered.
Or be forced to watch 12 continuous hours of Raiders grindball highlights
I like the cut of your jib.
PS what's a jib?
PPS does PJ work for NSW police?
Hi Azza,
A jib is the triangular sail at the front of a ship. I believe the particular shape (cut) of the jib on old ships made their nationality recognisable from a distance.
Also, to be included in the lowlights reel could be Starling refuse to pass to anyone after making a brief run / receiving an offload.
Thank you. PS is the poop deck really what I think it is?
greeneyed wrote:Why should we stay quiet? I don’t understand why so many people say “shush” when we’re just standing up for ourselves. We shouldn’t stay silent when we’re not being given a fair go. The people at the NRL in Sydney would prefer to ignore us, and have things swept under the carpet.
Cause when it has zero impact on the outcome of the game they just look like a sook and a sore loser
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
It will have no impact on the outcome of the game, but it should have an impact on ensuring that procedures are fair and reasonable in the future. The NRL isn't protecting our interests unless we stand up for ourselves... who cares what Sharks fans think?
This thread is bonkers GE. I think you've actually managed to find a group of people who want trainers more involved in the game.
Raider Azz wrote: ↑April 2, 2024, 3:27 pm
Yeah this whole talk about how it looks is dumb. Nobody at the club is claiming it cost us the game and it isn't unreasonable to want to hold the trainer accountable.
And that's all it is.
Trainers annoy me. Watching them on the field all game is frustrating.
Holdsworth was a former goal kicker off memory, and a mediocre NRL player.
He should know better than to go anywhere near the goal kicker.
The spiral of silence refers to the idea that when people fail to speak, the price of speaking rises. As the price to speak rises, still fewer speak out, which further causes the price to rise, so that fewer people yet will speak out, until a whole culture or nation is silenced. This is what happened in Germany.
If you do not speak, you are not being neutral, but are contributing to the success of the thing you refuse to name and condemn.
greeneyed wrote:Why should we stay quiet? I don’t understand why so many people say “shush” when we’re just standing up for ourselves. We shouldn’t stay silent when we’re not being given a fair go. The people at the NRL in Sydney would prefer to ignore us, and have things swept under the carpet.
Cause when it has zero impact on the outcome of the game they just look like a sook and a sore loser
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
It will have no impact on the outcome of the game, but it should have an impact on ensuring that procedures are fair and reasonable in the future. The NRL isn't protecting our interests unless we stand up for ourselves... who cares what Sharks fans think?
This thread is bonkers GE. I think you've actually managed to find a group of people who want trainers more involved in the game.
We actually have our own fans saying we shouldn’t be raising this issue… after what happened in the 2019 Grand Final!
Incidentally, our own fans are worried about how our club “looks” to other fans. You should see how other fans are carrying on on some social media platforms over this. It has actually reached ridiculous, hilarious “heights”.
greeneyed wrote:Why should we stay quiet? I don’t understand why so many people say “shush” when we’re just standing up for ourselves. We shouldn’t stay silent when we’re not being given a fair go. The people at the NRL in Sydney would prefer to ignore us, and have things swept under the carpet.
Cause when it has zero impact on the outcome of the game they just look like a sook and a sore loser
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
It will have no impact on the outcome of the game, but it should have an impact on ensuring that procedures are fair and reasonable in the future. The NRL isn't protecting our interests unless we stand up for ourselves... who cares what Sharks fans think?
This thread is bonkers GE. I think you've actually managed to find a group of people who want trainers more involved in the game.
We actually have our own fans saying we shouldn’t be raising this issue… after what happened in the 2019 Grand Final!
Incidentally, our own fans are worried about how our club “looks” to other fans. You should see how other fans are carrying on on some social media platforms over this. It has actually reached ridiculous, hilarious “heights”.
I’ve been critical of the club playing victim in the past and shifting blame for poor performance but I’ve no issues with the way this has been raised. It wasn’t a heat of the moment emotional issue in the presser it was a respectful please explain. I noted the trainer’s actions in the game day thread - it seemed a very deliberate action to put Fog off the kick. That said I wouldn’t have been totally shocked if it was the Raiders runner But given it was the sharks runner they deserve whatever comes their way which I’m guessing won’t be much.